Saturday, September 10, 2005

Fairy Tales and Freakery.

The Brothers Grimm
2005, USA
Terry Gilliam
35mm

Terry Gilliam and I have never really gotten along. I find his comedy too broad, his metaphors too obvious, and his pacing too panicked and frantic, like the last few seconds of a homemade sex tape after the condom breaks. He, in turn, finds me crude, endlessly repetitive, and rigidly formal in my deliberate soullessness, like an engineer running trains to Buchenwald. I don’t think he’s met a wide-angle lens he hasn’t liked, and he’s been known to comment that I go through similes like a junkie collapsing veins. Nevertheless, we’ve carried on with both our lives with minimal animosity, giving grudging respect when it is due. In his case, congratulations must be bestowed for 12 Monkeys, which is in my opinion the best science fiction film ever made, and I will admit that The Adventures of Baron Munchausen was a childhood favorite, with the sad pathos of the lead character penetrating even my young and as yet untwisted mind as something generally unheard of in children’s films. However, I will never forgive Time Bandits for its reliance on midgets, which contributed in no small part to the little freaks being accepted in modern society and given the right to vote despite the evidence that they are not in fact people but rather descendants of ancient Scandinavian trolls. Brazil is almost hysterical in its hallucinogenic reinterpretation of Orwellian dystopia, a problem which is tripled in intensity on the director’s cut, and I’m entirely too violently conservative to condone the drug-fueled excess of Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas. The problem with Gilliam, aside from the fact that he would very much like to be Tim Burton but has yet to discover the right combination of peyote buttons and Vincent Prince films necessary to affect that alchemical transmutation, is that he makes children’s films, yet is clearly of the opinion that children are crazy little monsters who like nothing more than to swirl around kaleidoscopically and watch things die.

Child, troll, or midget? Either way, it should be gassed.

This inherent flaw is what both makes and breaks The Brothers Grimm. It’s been frequently stated that the film is too scary for children, and too stupid for adults, and this is very true. The film moves entirely too fast to allow any emotional investment in the characters, running at a speed that would outrace a condensed TV edit of The Goonies, especially in its miserable first act, which is almost bad enough to sink the film. Things slow down slightly afterwards, and get progressively more interesting by incorporating the darker elements of traditional fairy tales and mixing them all together, coming off as if Cradle of Filth wrote The Chronicles of Narnia. I couldn’t helped but be drawn in by these genuinely terrifying moments, like when a spider-possessed horse eats a child or the princess buried alive and rotting from plague, but then one of Gilliam’s exaggerated Python-esque performances would smack me in the face with a buffoonish slapstick routine or a terrible accent. Chief among these offenders is Peter Stormare, a fine Swedish actor who for some reason is cast as an Italian torturer, a sin against dialect and suspension of disbelief almost as great as the inclusion of Christopher Lambert as a Scot in Highlander. Stormare sputters and staggers through his performance like a sedated ballerina, though he is almost topped by Gilliam favorite Jonathan Pryce as a French general who speaks like the “cherchez-la vache” guys in The Holy Grail.

Why does The Highlander look like plaid bear and sound like Inspector Clouseau?

Thankfully, those terrible performances are offset somewhat by the film’s leads, particularly Matt Damon, who has always had a pleasant screen presence unless he’s being poisoned by a close proximity to Ben Affleck, the Kryptonite of talent. Damon plays Will Grimm, one of the titular brothers, who travels from town to town faking supernatural phenomenon and then charging the villagers to banish the ‘demons’, kind of like Scooby Doo if Shaggy was a grifter. His brother is played by Heath Ledger, who I thought was a master of dialect after seeing him blend completely into his performance as the slurry Skip Engbom in Lords of Dogtown. However, it has now become apparent that Leger has drunk himself into both incomprehensibility and patchy facial hair. The brothers are joined by Lena Headey, who plays town outcast Angelika as a kind of rough approximation of Keira Knightley. Damon is funny, Angelika is suitably mysterious, and Leger is unintelligible, but there is an element of fun to their performances that’s hard to resist. Which, I suppose, is a good enough description of the film.

12 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Software Only: More thoughts on Memeorandum 2.0
I posted last night about the new version of Memeorandum being available, and why it looked really great, especially with the new Tech focused content aggregation.
Hi, I was just blog surfing and found you! If you are interested, go see my custom golf club related site. It isn't anything special but you may still find something of interest.

7:42 PM  
Anonymous Argh said...

See what happens when you praise Matt Damon. All hell has broken loose and Stan has risen in an attempt to sell golf clubs.

9:30 PM  
Blogger Ash Karreau said...

I only praise Damon in relation to Affleck, the true Son of Stan.

8:52 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Ben Affleck, the Kryptonite of talent

Hey, Ash, whatever it is yer smokin' or shootin' or drinkin', if it gets ya gems like these, pass it around, will ya, so maybe the rest of us can almost as be creative and colorful as you?

Thanks!

11:40 PM  
Blogger Fr. John McCuen said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

11:41 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

can almost as be creative and colorful as you?

and maybe even get our syntax right?

Let's try that again: can almost be as creative and colorful as you...

11:42 PM  
Blogger Sam Kahn said...

Pretty spot-on.

5:24 AM  
Blogger Ash Karreau said...

Yeah, Sam, I think I had pretty much the same opinion as you, judging from your review. And Anonymous, don't worry about syntax. I barely spell check my posts, so there's no judgement here. Unless you're a member of a minority. Or female. Or an immigrant. Or you don't agree with me.

11:53 AM  
Blogger Ash Karreau said...

Oh, and anonymous, I don't have a secret tonic or funny drug. It's just cocaine.

12:42 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Mortiis is cool, you shouldn`t diss him.

Pete

3:03 PM  
Blogger Ash Karreau said...

I know. I'm going to see him play in October. That doesn't make him any less funny looking, however.

3:19 PM  
Blogger cslewisfan221 said...

Apparently, there are Narnia Events going on all over the country that are movie "sneek peeks". I just found some information at Narnia Resources

7:20 PM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home